Three quotes. One call. Zero pressure.
2026 Pricing

Siding Costs on Long Island

Real pricing from our contractor network. All estimates based on a typical 2,000 sq ft Long Island home including labor, materials, and old siding removal.

Vinyl Siding

Vinyl Siding

Most Popular

Most popular — low cost, low maintenance

Pros
  • Lowest installed cost on Long Island
  • Zero painting or staining required
  • Wide color and profile selection
  • Withstands salt air better than wood
Cons
  • - Can warp in extreme heat
  • - Less impact-resistant than fiber cement
  • - Colors fade over 15–20 years
Lifetime limited (varies by manufacturer)20-40 year lifespanBest for: Budget-conscious homeowners wanting a clean, modern look
$8,500 – $16,000
$5 – $11 / sq ft/sq ft
Get Quotes
James Hardie Fiber Cement

James Hardie Fiber Cement

Premium Pick

Premium durability — the Long Island standard

Pros
  • Non-combustible and termite-proof
  • Handles coastal weather and salt spray
  • ColorPlus factory finish lasts 15+ years
  • Strongest ROI on Long Island resale
Cons
  • - Higher installed cost
  • - Heavier — needs experienced crew
  • - Requires repainting every 15–20 years
30-year non-prorated (ColorPlus)30-50 year lifespanBest for: Homeowners planning to stay 10+ years, or selling soon (best ROI)
$18,000 – $35,000
$12 – $24 / sq ft/sq ft
Get Quotes
Cedar Shake Siding

Cedar Shake Siding

Classic charm — natural beauty

Pros
  • Natural beauty — no synthetic can match it
  • Classic Long Island architectural style
  • Good insulation value (R-0.87 per inch)
  • Can be stained any color
Cons
  • - Requires staining every 3–5 years
  • - Susceptible to rot, insects, and mold
  • - Highest maintenance of all options
Manufacturer material warranty (varies)25-40 year lifespanBest for: Heritage homes, waterfront properties, style-first homeowners
$22,000 – $42,000
$15 – $28 / sq ft/sq ft
Get Quotes
Insulated Vinyl Siding

Insulated Vinyl Siding

Energy upgrade — vinyl with foam backing

Pros
  • Reduces energy bills 10–20%
  • Eliminates wall flex and rattle
  • Better impact resistance than standard vinyl
  • R-value boost (R-2 to R-5 added)
Cons
  • - Costs 30–50% more than standard vinyl
  • - Same color fade issue as standard vinyl
  • - Fewer profile options than standard
Lifetime limited + energy guarantee25-40 year lifespanBest for: Homeowners focused on energy savings and comfort
$12,000 – $22,000
$8 – $15 / sq ft/sq ft
Get Quotes
Engineered Wood (LP SmartSide)

Engineered Wood (LP SmartSide)

Wood look without wood problems

Pros
  • Authentic wood appearance
  • Lighter than fiber cement (easier install)
  • Impact-resistant (won't crack like Hardie)
  • Paintable — unlimited color options
Cons
  • - Requires repainting every 8–12 years
  • - Moisture damage risk if not properly sealed
  • - Less fire-resistant than fiber cement
50-year substrate, 15-year finish30-50 year lifespanBest for: Homeowners wanting wood aesthetics with less maintenance
$14,000 – $26,000
$9 – $17 / sq ft/sq ft
Get Quotes

How We Source These Prices

Pricing data comes from completed projects in our contractor network, cross-referenced with Remodeling Magazine's Cost vs. Value report and regional HomeAdvisor data. All figures include labor, materials, starter strips, j-channel, and old siding removal for a typical 2,000 sq ft home. Your actual cost depends on house condition, material grade, number of windows/doors, and contractor.

4.8 Rating
340+ reviews
Licensed & Insured
Every contractor verified
15 Contractors
Vetted network
Free Matching
No cost, no obligation

Ready to Get Real Quotes?

Stop guessing. Get 3 free, detailed estimates from vetted Long Island contractors.

Get 3 Free Quotes (631) 500-7663

Three quotes. One call. Zero pressure.